top of page

Forum Posts

Cindy Hansen
Mar 14, 2025
In Effective Therapist Forum
In a recent episode of the enlightening podcast, "The Book Case," Drs. Scott Miller and Dan Lewis sat down with historian Dr. Eric Caplan to explore the evolution of psychiatry—an area transitioning from ancient traditional healing to modern medical methodologies. By tracing the historical development of psychological care, we gain an appreciation of today’s practices and gather valuable insights for creating a more individualized approach to future treatments. Dr. Caplan's engaging conversation unravels the origins, significant milestones, and ongoing challenges in psychiatric care, with a focus on meeting individual needs over adhering strictly to conventional models.  "The idea that there are somatic hooks to hook onto—mental illness to something biological—is compelling and often right. But it doesn't mean that everything that might appear as mental illness traces back to the body." - Dr. Caplan Inspired by this insightful discussion, the article aims to illuminate how the rich history of psychiatry can guide us toward a future where personalized care is emphasized. Throughout the conversation, the importance of asking the right questions and monitoring individual progress was highlighted—an approach that ensures mental health practices become increasingly effective and compassionate. Understanding the roots of psychiatry is crucial to comprehending its present dynamics and its future development. As Dr. Caplan articulates, the significance lies not only in charting historical trajectories but also in recognizing the persistent relevance of foundational practices in contemporary treatment. The historical evolution of psychiatry has been influenced by numerous factors, including cultural dynamics, economic changes, and advancements in transportation.  Initially, individuals experiencing mental health issues often turned to clergy or traditional healers. During this time, the medical field itself was establishing its identity and seeking to distinguish itself from other healing methods. The professionalization of medicine was key in evolving psychiatry into a respected field. With their extensive training and understanding of the human body, physicians claimed authority over mental health—a domain previously explored by spiritual and lay healers.  As Dr. Caplan notes, early mental health care was born more out of necessity and societal evolution than scientific innovation. This distinction is particularly significant when considering how much of past medical practices, thought redundant in other areas of health, persist in psychotherapy and mental care. The merging of evolving scientific understanding with pre-existing cultural and spiritual healing methods created a complex landscape. New practices emerged, yet older ones persisted, often unaffected by paradigm shifts seen in other medical disciplines.  This historical context helps us understand why contemporary psychiatry still navigates the balance between a scientifically grounded approach and the remnants of its non-medical origins. By delving into the layers of psychiatry's past, you gain a better appreciation for its ongoing transformation and the necessity of a patient-centered approach that adapts to and grows with each individual's unique experience. Hysteria and the Emergence of Mental Health Care To understand the historical context of mental health care, we must journey back to the 19th century when the fabric of psychological treatment began to fray with the concept of hysteria. This was a time when the industrial revolution was radically transforming society at unprecedented speeds, and as transportation and industry surged forward, societal pressures amplified, leading to a new wave of mental health challenges that were often misunderstood.  Dr. Caplan sheds light on how doctors of that era grappled with symptoms appearing psychological in nature yet manifesting without apparent physical injury—a phenomenon particularly evident with men involved in railway accidents. Despite showing no external wounds, they exhibited symptoms we would now recognize as post-traumatic stress disorder. During that time, prevailing gender biases deemed it inconceivable for men to exhibit hysteria, a condition considered predominantly female and linked to women's physical anatomy. As a solution, a new condition termed “spinal concussion” or “railway spine” emerged, lacking a robust scientific foundation yet satisfying the era's need to rationalize these symptoms in men.  The recognition of psychological distress, thus, began its slow journey within the medical community, shaped as much by sociocultural currents as by medical insights. The nascent field of mental health care arose from these misunderstandings, sparking debates over the very nature of mental illness—an ongoing debate that continues to inform how mental health treatment is approached today and in the future. The Role of Cultural Influences in Early Psychological Practices Diving into the historical roots of psychiatry, you'll quickly find that cultural influences have played a pivotal role in shaping early psychological practices. Many concepts and therapies we recognize today were born from a confluence of cultural, economic, and societal shifts. Consider the 19th century, for instance, when society witnessed the rise of social classes focused on intellectual pursuits amid significant economic advancements. This period provided fertile ground for the development of mental health care, creating an environment ripe for examining the mind with newfound interest.  The advent of transportation technologies, such as railroads, further fueled this climate of exploration and wonder. As people traveled at unprecedented speeds, they experienced accidents that, while often leaving them physically unscathed, resulted in symptoms similar to what's now recognized as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This connection between psychological phenomena and the physical body sparked curiosity and investigation, ultimately highlighting the possibility that mental and emotional injuries could stem from experiences rather than solely physical harm. This revelation began shifting cultural perceptions of mental illness.  During this period, the professionalization of medicine added complexity to the cultural landscape. It provoked questions about whether disturbances of thought, mood, and behavior always required a physician's intervention. Before psychiatric services gained widespread acceptance, individuals often sought help from ministers, spiritual guides, or lay healers, reflecting a diverse array of cultural practices. This historical context underscores how deeply intertwined cultural dynamics are with the evolution of mental health care. The Evolution of Psychotherapy: From the Couch to the Brain The progression of psychotherapy has been marked by significant shifts in methodology and focus. Initially, talk therapy, rooted in Freudian psychoanalysis, dominated the field. This approach emphasized understanding unconscious motives stemming from developmental and personality issues, often visualized as a patient on a couch discussing their internal conflicts with an expert psychoanalyst. During those early days, a lack of biologically grounded evidence often led to subjective interpretations of mental health issues.  As psychotherapy advanced through the 20th century, the field began to embrace a more scientifically grounded understanding of mental health, leading to a significant transition toward the medical model. A key example of this shift is observed in the Osheroff v. Chestnut Lodge case, which highlighted the limitations of relying solely on psychoanalysis. This case involved a Dr. Ray Osheroff, who was admitted to Chestnut Lodge suffering from severe depression. Upon admission, he was informed that medication would interfere with his therapy and was treated exclusively with psychoanalysis, leading to a severe deterioration in his condition. This treatment approach resulted in legal action against the lodge, which centered on the hospital's denial of standard care by excluding medication from his treatment plan. Dr. Caplan describes this case as a catalyst for change, emphasizing the importance of medication as a viable treatment option, sparking what he refers to as a "sea change in the practice of psychiatry." Entering the 21st century, the fascination with the brain and cognitive functions became central to psychotherapy. Psychoanalysis gave way to approaches that combined biological and cognitive perspectives, notably Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). These therapies prioritize empirical research and aim to provide measurable benefits, aligning with institutional desires to endorse treatments likely to yield positive results.  While the shift towards a medicalized view has led to considerable advances, there is a growing recognition of the need for humility in addressing mental health's complexities. Accepting the current limitations of our understanding, alongside the nuanced interplay of genetic, biological, and environmental factors contributing to mental health issues, paves the way for more personalized and adaptive treatment methods.  Ultimately, the evolution of psychotherapy appears to be steering towards a fusion of scientific inquiry with human-centered care, emphasizing feedback-informed treatment. This approach respects each individual's unique experiences and highlights the importance of patient-centered care that adapts to the evolving needs and progress of those seeking mental health support. A Century of Change: The Shift from Psychoanalysis to Medication The field of psychiatry has experienced a significant transformation over the past century, shifting from the once-dominant practice of psychoanalysis to a greater reliance on medication as a primary mode of treatment. This evolution is grounded in the development of the medical model, which aims to deliver measurable and evidence-based benefits to patients suffering from mental health issues.  Historically, mental illness treatment was rooted in psychoanalytic methods, requiring extensive sessions over many years to address underlying psychological conflicts and assumed personality formations. As Dr. Caplan elaborates, the origins of what we now recognize as mental illness were once thought to be deeply embedded in psychological traumas. Consequently, treatments focused intensely on unraveling these past experiences through specialized therapies such as Freudian psychoanalysis.  However, the rise of medication in psychiatric treatment has defined a new era. Following landmark cases like that of Dr. Ray Osheroff and Chestnut Lodge in the early 1980s, the psychiatric community began shifting focus. Dr. Caplan cites this case as pivotal in illustrating the growing trend toward evidence-based medicine, emphasizing the delivery of measurable benefits rather than strictly adhering to psychoanalytic methods over several years. The subsequent eightfold increase in antidepressant prescriptions suggests a growing priority on medication as a more viable and scalable solution to mental health issues.  Yet, this shift towards pharmacotherapy is not without complexities. Dr. Caplan humorously remarks on the 'chemical imbalance' theory, which, despite a lack of concrete scientific evidence, serves as a compelling narrative that aids in the marketing of medications. This stands in contrast to medical fields like cardiology, where measurable biological markers guide treatment decisions.  In response to these historical shifts, a new, patient-centric approach is gaining traction in psychology and psychiatry: Feedback-Informed Treatment (FIT). Unlike strict adherence to a single therapeutic model—be it the depth-oriented psychoanalysis of the past or today's medication-focused solutions—FIT promotes continuous monitoring and adaptation based on individual progress. Tools such as the Outcome Rating Scale (ORS) and the Session Rating Scale (SRS) were initially developed to provide brief, consistent measures of progress for individuals in therapy. Despite their potential, these simple tools have often been overshadowed by more medically oriented scales like the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7 (GAD-7) and the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), developed by Pfizer, which diagnose and track mental health conditions in a manner more aligned with the current medical model.  The tension between these approaches underscores a broader cultural and professional reckoning within psychology and psychiatry: should mental health care focus on a patient's experience, adapting to their evolving needs, or adhere to the rigid structures of a medicalized framework? Moving forward, a re-evaluation may be necessary—one that blends the compassion and flexibility of FIT with scientific rigor. Ultimately, this fosters an environment where the complex interplay of mind, body, and environment is navigated with humility and a patient-centered focus. Feedback-Informed Treatment: A Patient-Centered Revolution In the evolving field of psychiatry, a significant shift towards patient-centered care is gaining momentum. At the heart of this transformation is the practice of feedback-informed treatment (FIT), emphasizing the unique experiences and progress of individuals rather than relying on a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach. This patient-centric model values listening to and respecting patients' stories, leveraging measurement-based care to tailor treatments that are more personalized, flexible, and effective.  Feedback-informed treatment shines as a beacon of hope, particularly when traditional models fall short in addressing the diverse needs of those suffering from mental health issues. Dr. Caplan underscored this by highlighting how many psychiatric treatments have heavily depended on a medical model focused on medication as the primary intervention. Yet, this approach may not suit everyone. For instance, in Dr. Osheroff's case, exclusive reliance on psychoanalysis without considering alternative solutions adversely affected his well-being. If professionals had been more attentive to his feedback and closely monitored his condition, they could have identified the existing treatment as ineffective and harmful, necessitating a re-evaluation.  The practice of regularly assessing and integrating patients' experiences into their treatment plans is a hallmark of feedback-informed treatment. Rather than strictly adhering to predefined protocols or dogmatic approaches, FIT fosters ongoing communication between therapists and patients. This dynamic and responsive model tailors interventions based on real-time feedback, significantly enhancing patient satisfaction and outcomes.  Adopting feedback-informed treatment can greatly benefit contemporary psychiatric practices, where the complexity of mental health demands individualized care. Through constant evaluation of treatment effectiveness, mental health professionals can adjust methods and interventions to align better with a patient’s unique needs, promoting a more person-centered model of care. This approach encourages patient engagement and helps build a foundation of trust, a crucial component in any successful therapeutic relationship.  Embracing this more personalized approach can significantly reduce stigma and enhance the lives of those facing mental health challenges. By continuously monitoring an individual’s progress, care providers can identify the most beneficial treatments, recognizing that what works for one person may not be appropriate for another. A Look Forward: Reimagining the Future of Psychiatry The future of psychiatry promises to bridge the gap between traditional medical models and more human-centered approaches. While standardized scales like the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7 (GAD-7) and the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) are currently foundational for diagnosing and assessing mental health conditions, they offer a fixed framework. The journey forward lies in balancing these symptom-focused diagnoses with more adaptable, patient-centered feedback systems.  Conventional psychiatric tools often present significant limitations due to their narrow focus on select symptoms. This limited perspective can exclude the broader narratives of a patient's life, potentially hindering the transition to truly individualized care practices. While clinicians may rely on standardized checklists, these may not fully capture a patient's holistic well-being or the quality of their engagement with therapy. Such limitations underscore the pressing need for innovative strategies in psychiatric practices that recognize each individual's evolving therapeutic journey.  Embracing tools that go beyond merely tracking symptom reduction will be key to the future of psychiatry. By considering the emotional, psychological, and social facets of mental health recovery, we can create a more comprehensive and personalized treatment model. This nuanced approach paves the way for tailored solutions that accommodate the complexities of each person's unique experience.  Looking forward, the blend of human-centered AI in mental health care and substance use, along with the cutting-edge application of predictive algorithms, creates a promising path for enhancing care. By reporting the success probability at each session, patients and providers can evaluate the potential success of a treatment plan. A success probability index enables clinicians to customize interventions effectively and adjust their strategies in real-time, boosting the effectiveness of mental health treatments. This patient involvement nurtures empowerment and strengthens the bond with therapists, turning the healing journey into a personalized collaboration. Effective communication and transparency are crucial components in evolving treatment plans to match each patient's unique goals and circumstances, leading to more meaningful and lasting recovery.  Dr. Caplan's exploration of psychiatry's progression emphasizes the importance of a truly person-centered approach in mental health care, aligning with measurement-based care principles. As revealed in the interview, historical methods like psychoanalysis and subsequent medication have often placed ideology above individual patient progress. Toward the interview's conclusion, Scott Miller notes the potential of engaging directly with individuals about their experiences, rather than stringently following prescribed models. This dialogue enables a transition in mental health care from merely addressing symptoms to fostering overall well-being. This approach resonates with current trends in measurement-based care and AI-driven strategies, focusing on early detection of distress signals to prevent setbacks and enhance the overall patient experience.  Watch the full Book Case interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWVefeZOR1Y
The Evolution of Psychiatry: Emphasizing Patient-Centered Progress Over Prescriptive Models content media
0
0
4
Cindy Hansen
Feb 15, 2025
In Effective Therapist Forum
Are you exploring alternatives to support your mental health recovery? Dive into the realm of holistic health and discover innovative practices that promote healing and balance. This comprehensive guide, "Unlocking Holistic Health: Evaluating Its Impact on Mental Health Recovery," is designed to offer you insights into the latest research and efficacy of holistic methods. Learn how these practices can be integrated into your daily life to support your mental wellness journey. Learn More Are you curious about how energy medicine can enhance your mental health recovery journey? Techniques such as Reiki, acupressure, and therapeutic touch offer powerful pathways to healing. Discover these practices' science and real-world impact in our essential read: Unlocking Holistic Health: Evaluating Its Impact on Mental Health Recovery.  Discover the Power of Energy Medicine   • Reiki: Harness the universal life force to promote balance and relaxation. • Acupressure: Utilize finger pressure techniques to stimulate energy flow and relieve tension. • Therapeutic Touch: Experience healing through intention and touch to harmonize your entire being.   Why Read This Book?  Explore how these ancient practices are gaining scientific backing for their efficacy in mental health recovery. You'll gain insights from recent studies, participate in a self-discovery journey, and learn ways to leverage these practices in your life.  Empower Your Healing Journey  Through this captivating read, you'll empower yourself with the knowledge to connect with your inner wisdom, improve self-awareness, and develop coping skills to support your mental wellness. Request a Copy
Unlocking Holistic Health: Your Path to Mental Wellness content media
0
2
23
Cindy Hansen
Aug 02, 2024
In Effective Therapist Forum
Living with depression, anxiety or unmanaged pain can certainly be challenging. The journey towards healing and wholeness often feels like a maze, and at times, a steep mountain to climb. You might be wondering how you can break the cycle, how you can touch the hope that seems so elusive. Here's where the cutting-edge approach of holistic life coaching with a Therapy Outcome Monitoring System (TOMS), introduced by Holistic Research Canada, comes into play. A tool designed to track Goals, Distress, and Alliance data, it sheds light on even the darkest paths towards healing.  "In essence, a holistic life coach becomes your collaborative partner in recovery, while TOMS serves as the compass guiding each step." Interested, yet unsure what this actually means for you? Read on! This article will make sense of how using the TOMS system in your journey can not only refine your healing targets but ensure the actualization of your wellness goals. So, let's dive in and see how getting better is not only possible but also more easily achievable when working with this intricate balance of art and science. Tracking Progress through TOMS: Gaining Clarity and Assurance  If you're working with a holistic life coach using the Therapy Outcome Monitoring System (TOMS), you're in a unique position. This system uses a clear structure that makes it easy to track your progress. This is super important for anyone dealing with depression, anxiety, and pain because the path to coping isn't a straight line.  TOMS uses goals, your level of distress, and your connection with your coach (the Alliance) to create a picture of how you're doing. It turns your goals into something more than wishful thinking - it turns them into measurable outcomes, helping make your dreams a reality. Knowing you're on the right path gives you a sense of control, easing your stress along the way.  But TOMS doesn't stop there. It also evaluates your stress or distress levels, which helps you see if there are patterns in what you're going through. If you can identify a pattern, it's much easier to manage it - meaning you have a better chance at handling stress in your life. Seeing a decrease in your distress level is a clear signal that your holistic life coaching is working.  In addition to all of this, TOMS measures your Alliance - the relationship between you and your coach. A strong relationship here has been shown to improve therapy results. Knowing you're in a place of mutual understanding and empathy can reassure you on your journey.  So, to sum up, TOMS can validate and enrich your healing journey by regularly measuring your Goals, Distress, and Alliance. It's a prime example of how technology and science can enhance therapy and lead to better results. Six Benefits of Using TOMS in Holistic Life Coaching   For those coping with depression, anxiety, or chronic pain, TOMS offers quite a few advantages. These include:  1. Comprehensive Approach   TOMS stands out for its inclusive viewpoint. It combines mental, emotional, and physical health, which helps coaches design wide-ranging plans to improve every aspect of a client's well-being.   2. Precise Target Setting   The 'Goals' part of TOMS refers to a client's therapy objectives. This focus on goals allows for clear aims to be devised and a methodical approach to achieving them, instead of simply stating the idea of 'improvement'.   3. Regular Progress Monitoring   Steady monitoring of 'Distress' gives a real-time view of a client's struggles. Frequent updates can highlight patterns and identify potential causes while showing progress. This allows both the coach and client to quickly respond to any changes.   4. Stronger Coach-Client Relationships   The 'Alliance' part of TOMS emphasizes the importance of a good working relationship between the coach and client in the success of the therapy. Frequent monitoring and responding to feedback can strengthen this bond, leading to better teamwork, increased trust, and, ultimately, improved outcomes.   5. Motivation and Accountability   When clients can see concrete data on their progress, they often feel more driven and involved in their treatment. This sense of control and accountability can positively affect their commitment to the therapy plan.   6. Evidence-Based Decision Making   TOMS provides valuable, data-driven insights that serve as a practical tool for making decisions about treatment. Coaches can adjust strategies based on measured progress, resulting in personalized and effective therapeutic pathways.  TOMS: A New Method for Better Results  TOMS is an innovative method used to enhance the results of holistic life coaching in treating depression, anxiety, and pain. This system focuses on three main areas: Goals, Distress, and Alliance. These areas help to shape your recovery process.  In holistic life coaching, TOMS offers several benefits. Holistic coaching considers both your physical and mental health. Just like this, TOMS uses an all-inclusive approach to measure and oversee your progress, ensuring it's precise and full.   Having Goals is essential for recovery. If you're dealing with depression, anxiety, or chronic pain, these goals can serve as a light in the dark. With TOMS, your coach can stay on top of your goals, making them an integral part of your recovery journey.  Distress varies between individuals. Your physical or emotional pain can change due to various factors. TOMS helps your coach measure your distress levels to spot patterns and likely triggers. This information can help personalize and improve your strategies to manage distress.  A strong Alliance between you and your coach is also important. This relationship should be based on trust, respect, and understanding. TOMS regularly checks the strength and quality of your alliance, creating an environment that encourages growth and support.   In short, TOMS provides a full view of your therapy process by using these important areas. If you're suffering from depression, anxiety, or chronic pain, TOMS can transform your therapy experience, bringing about clarity, progress, and wellness.   TOMS also encourages motivation. Watching your progress in real-time can uplift your spirits and encourage a positive mindset. It also keeps coaches inspired as they observe the positive effects of their methods.  The data-supported decisions made through TOMS are crucial for therapy. These decisions reduce uncertainty. The coach can form a more effective therapeutic alliance by altering strategies based on dependable data and your feedback.   Using TOMS promotes accountability. It reminds you of your responsibility in achieving your goals. It also keeps coaches accountable for using effective methods and making necessary adjustments.   In summary, TOMS, with its focus on Goals, Distress, and Alliance (GDA) data, offers a new perspective for improved results in therapy. It strengthens the holistic approach, which takes into account the mind, body, and spirit. With TOMS, both coach and client play active roles, leading individuals back to wellness and fullness.  Holistic-Coaching BC Consultation https://www.wix.app/bookings/9c9987ad-c36a-410b-b53a-bf48f71049a2/service/1157fab6-efeb-42ec-ab54-0b4954091d3d/details?d=https://www.cindyhansencft.com/service-page/holistic-coaching-bc-consultation
0
9
76
Cindy Hansen
Aug 02, 2024
In Effective Therapist Forum
Are you pondering the question, "Does therapy really work?" You're not alone. Many folks wonder about this often-confusing topic. Our goal here is to escort you through a critical exploration into why people need therapy, why some people shun it, and the kind of mixed results one can expect. Sounds good? Let’s dive in.  “You're not alone in your quest to understand therapy. It's a journey and we're here to guide you every step of the way.” We'll also help you understand why you stand a better chance of success if you collaborate with feedback informed practitioners. These are professionals who use a Therapy Outcome Monitoring System (TOMS) to deliver superior results. On the surface, it may sound a bit complex, but don't fret. We're here to break it down for you in layman's terms.  • Understanding the need for therapy • Why do some people avoid therapy? • The expected mixed outcomes of therapy • The value of feedback-informed practitioners Stick with us, and you'll leave with a clear understanding of the multifaceted world of therapy - the good, the bad, and the outstandingly transformative! Ready to begin? Let's go. Understanding Therapy: What Is It and How Does It Work? Think of therapy, like a way of tuning the piano of your mind. When life's chords become discordant and distressing, it's time to consider a 'therapy intervention'. Whether we're dealing with emotional trauma, mental health issues, or just feeling 'stuck', therapy gives us the tools to face these challenges head-on.  But, remarkably, plenty of individuals shy away from therapy. Why? Because there's often stigmatization attached to seeking mental health support, and the prospect of dredging up painful emotions can be daunting. Plus, let's not forget the common misconception that therapy is only for those suffering from severe mental health issues. However, therapy is the lifeline reaching out amidst the stormy seas of our human condition. It's for everyone, whether you're battling ongoing psychological illness, or simply looking for emotional clarity and self-improvement.  But does therapy guarantee an escalation to emotional nirvana? Not always. Therapy, like most things worth pursuing, requires a genuine commitment and can sometimes lead to 'mixed results'. The key here is to understand that therapy's efficacy largely depends on the therapeutic relationship, the individual's engagement, and the techniques used during the therapy sessions.  And that's precisely where feedback informed clinicians come into the picture! They use a therapy outcome monitoring system, guiding us to better understand our growth, pinpoint areas for improvement, and acknowledge our progress along the treatment journey. TOMS promotes a collaborative approach in therapy and offers quantifiable validation of psychological techniques. Where can we find such transformative therapy? Good news! These inclusive therapy outcome monitoring systems are implemented in traditional therapy settings, as well as in digital mental health services such as apps and teletherapy! This makes therapy even more accessible and attuned to our modern, digital age.  Using this approach helps us understand therapy better. It builds a stronger bond between the therapist and client and enhances trust through personalized and flexible methods. This tool also lets us compare results across different clients, providing insight into how effective the therapy is and helping us spot patterns in clients' progress.  So, when we take a step back and look at the bigger picture, opting for therapy - especially one with an outcome monitoring system - is like stepping out from the shadows into the light of clearer understanding and better mental health. So why wait? Unraveling the Skepticism: Why Some People Steer Clear of Therapy When exploring the question 'Does therapy work?', it's crucial to consider the various elements at play that can influence therapy's effectiveness. It's widely accepted that therapy can indeed be beneficial; however, the exact level of success varies greatly between individuals - there's really no 'one size fits all' when it comes to mental health support. Some participants might even emerge from experiences in therapeutic situations with worsened conditions, with around 5-10% of adult clients in clinical trials falling into this category.  Moving onto why people don't go to therapy, there are numerous reasons cited by potential clients. Some exhibit a reduced willingness to participate in or commit to therapy, as they may struggle to see the potential benefits. They may be in the throes of deep depression, lacking motivation, or wrestling with frustration and anxiety. The thought of additional responsibilities could seem overwhelming.  Beyond individual clients, therapists may also contribute to these mixed results. Struggling with the burden of additional responsibilities, some therapists and trainees understandably feel overloaded, leading to obstacles like not following procedures, neglecting data collection, or forgetting to schedule appointments.  It's often seen that therapists unintentionally bring bias into the therapy room. Such bias can obstruct a fair evaluation of a client's progress during therapy. Unfortunately, therapists may also overlook problem areas and struggle to accurately assess the positive impacts of treatment.  Improving Therapy Outcomes with Feedback Informed Practitioners and Monitoring Systems  Despite these challenges, there's hope on the horizon. New and effective strategies are emerging that can support a successful therapy experience. Among these strategies, working with feedback-informed practitioners who use therapy outcome monitoring systems can potentially lead to better results.  Practically speaking, therapy outcome monitoring systems are incredibly beneficial. Clients can use them to observe their own progress and note where they might need to improve. This unique feedback gives them a sense of control over their healing process.  But it's not just about the client. This system can also make the bond between therapist and client stronger by encouraging a shared, clear, and adaptable plan. Because of this system, communication improves, and goals become more visible. In essence, it acts as an extra layer of information that aids in understanding the one-on-one relationship between a client and therapist as well as the client's personal progress.  One detail often missed with this system is the ability to look at outcomes from different clients. With this feature, therapists can gain vital knowledge about their work and make better adjustments to improve their therapy outcomes. One person even suggested that knowing the outcomes of different therapists could improve their own therapy practices substantially.  With digital mental health services becoming more common, including these systems in traditional therapies could seriously boost client engagement and personalization. The truth is the future of therapy is likely in these informed therapy outcome monitoring systems. They make the normally gray area of therapy into something tangible and actionable, where success is not just hoped for, but expected. Exploring the Variable Outcomes: Why Therapy Doesn't Work for Everyone Many people don't always benefit from therapy, and there are various reasons for this. One main cause is a weak bond between the therapist and the client. This bond, called a therapeutic alliance, is crucial for therapy to work. If the client doesn't trust or feel understood by their therapist, they likely won't engage in therapy, lowering its effectiveness.  Mismatching therapy styles with a client's need also factored. Therapies come in many different forms and approaches. If the style used by the therapist doesn't suit or strike a chord with the client's specific issues, the therapy likely won't work. For example, a client dealing with past trauma might not find a benefit in a cognitive-behavioral approach if it doesn't address their trauma.  Therapy also demands active involvement and hard work from the client. If the client is hesitant to engage, unwilling to make changes, or deal with hard emotions and past experiences, therapy might not yield the desired outcomes. Many things can cause this, like fear of change, a lack of drive, or not being mentally prepared for therapy.  Last but not least, outside factors can affect how effective therapy is. Things like how much therapy costs, a lack of good mental health services, or the social stigma around seeking mental health help. They can stop individuals from kicking off therapy or make them quit therapy early on.  However, these hurdles are not unbeatable. For example, feedback-informed practitioners who use therapy outcome tracking systems can enhance how effective therapy is. These systems let therapists track their client's progress, fine-tune their approach based on feedback, ensuring the therapy meets the clients' needs. Benefitting from Data: How Feedback Informed Practitioners Boost Therapy Success You might wonder, how do feedback-informed practitioners drive success in therapy? And what's the role of real-time tracking and feedback? Let's dive in to establish why this approach can potentially revolutionize therapy outcomes.  Studies suggest that therapy outcomes significantly improve when a feedback-informed approach is involved. Research conducted by Harmon et al. (2007) discovered implementing therapist-client feedback and clinical support tools potently enhances the treatment outcomes, especially for potential treatment failures.  What does this mean for you? It essentially translates to an accelerated path to self-improvement. You feel empowered in your journey, where you can easily reflect on your progress, pinpoint areas of improvement, and recognize the leaps you've made in therapy.  A crucial part of the feedback-informed approach is the use of TOMS. These systems allow for monitoring clients' involvement, distress, and well-being - elements that are vital to tailoring personalized therapeutic interventions. Additionally, they offer insights on therapy effectiveness by comparing outcomes across different clients. The resultant 'therapy tailored by feedback' approach increases the likelihood of therapy success.  Furthermore, an invaluable ally in progressing this approach is the advent of mental health apps. Their incorporation within therapy lends to real-time tracking and on-demand feedback, providing yet another layer of personalization and control to clients.  Ideally, therapy operates less as a 'one-size-fits-all' model and more as a tailor-made journey designed to suit your specific needs. Evidently, the intervention of feedback-informed practitioner along with therapy outcome monitoring systems, as supported by numerous studies, accentuates this personalization, thereby escalating the effectiveness of therapy. If you have been hesitant or unsure about therapy, remember - it’s a tool that adjusts to you, not the other way around. And with the help of feedback-guided practitioners, you get a therapy experience that’s custom-built to help you succeed. Embracing Change: How Therapy Outcome Monitoring Systems Guide Treatment Adjustments Imagine winning a race without a measure of how far you've run or achieving academic excellence without feedback on your assignments. Sounds challenging? This is precisely how therapy used to be – a somewhat ambiguous process. But thanks to outcome monitoring systems, all that has changed significantly over the last decade.  So, what exactly are these systems? Think of therapy outcome monitoring systems as real-time tracking devices, scrutinizing your progress in therapy, assessing your wellbeing, involvement, and emotional distress. This isn't just about a tick on a progress chart though, it is a way of tailoring therapy to your specific needs while creating a collaborative and inclusive treatment plan.  Seeing your Progress Reflected Back  One of the crucial benefits of these systems is that they provide an opportunity for reflection. By monitoring your progress in therapy, you can identify areas for improvement and recognize the strides you've made, empowering you in your treatment journey. After all, witnessing your own progress helps keep the motivation high and reinforces the will to change.  An Integrated Approach  These monitoring systems function in a wide variety of therapy types- be it individual, group, couples', or family therapy. They capably measure and evaluate goals, track emotional distress, and monitor therapeutic alliance, thereby providing practitioners a comprehensive view of the treatment and necessary areas for adjustment.  Aiding the Practitioners  Routine outcome monitoring isn't just beneficial for the clients but also the therapists. It allows them to consistently gauge the effectiveness of their methods and modify their approach accordingly for more successful results. Just as a navigation system helps steer a ship to its intended direction, these systems guide practitioners to tweak and refine their therapeutic strategies most efficiently.  Increased Adoption  Recognizing the pivotal role of these systems in improving the quality of therapy, there is growing adoption in routine outcome monitoring in the field of mental health treatment. Technology has proven to be a friend in this revolution, with online systems supporting the implementation of routine outcome monitoring.  In conclusion, therapy outcome monitoring systems serve as robust pillars supporting the edifice of effective therapy. By providing real-time assessment, they make therapy a more transparent, tailored, and empowering process for every individual seeking help. Therapy Reinvented: The Promise of Feedback-Informed Practice and Outcome Monitoring Systems Ever wondered, "Does therapy really help?" You're not by yourself. The results vary a lot in therapy, and that's why some people are skeptical. But did you know that using a feedback-based and results-tracking system can really boost success in therapy?  This fresh approach lets you be a key player in your healing journey, not just on the receiving end of care. It's like using GPS for your emotional wellness, guiding your therapist to offer the best help for you. When you're involved in tracking your progress, and your therapist knows this data, your chances of positive results from therapy go up.  In a study by Solstad and others (2019), they found that patients like this way of tracking their progress. It lets them play a key role in their therapy sessions. The study highlights how important it is to have a therapy process that is flexible, works together with the patient, and focuses on outcomes. The more your therapist knows, the more they can tailor their approach to help you out - be it managing stress, coping with changes in life, or other emotional health issues. But what does this look like in practice? How does a therapist use feedback to inform their methodology?  Well, a single-session feedback system, for example, allows for immediate adjustment. Your responses to various feedback measures can guide your therapist in devising the next step in your treatment. This feedback loop creates a constantly evolving therapy plan that's tailor-made to fit you. It also permits immediate intervention if things aren't going as planned, leading to better overall results.  In essence, a feedback-informed practice coupled with a therapy outcome monitoring system bridges the gap between you and your therapist, allowing for a more personalized treatment. Additionally, when practiced correctly, it can lend to an enhanced understanding of how therapy works for different individuals, ultimately providing more insights into best practices in the therapy realm. Keep in mind, however, this doesn't mean this method is a magic cure-all. Therapy works differently for everyone, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution. What it does provide is a more tailored approach that leans into evidence and research - setting the stage for a potentially more effective therapy process. When all is said and done, the effectiveness of therapy hinges on many variables. Certainly, the introduction of feedback-informed practices and outcome monitoring systems stand to revolutionize the field, offering a more personalized, collaborative, and adaptable therapy approach. Moreover, these developments enable the therapy process to not only be guided by extensive research, but also instant feedback from patients. This way, treatment can continuously adapt to a patient's evolving needs. Nevertheless, every individual's therapy journey remains unique, and these systems should not be viewed as a panacea, but as another tool in our quest to optimize therapeutic outcomes and support people on their path to mental wellness.
Does Therapy Really Work? Untangling the Impact of Feedback-informed Therapists and Outcome Monitoring Systems on Treatment Success
 content media
1
9
67
Cindy Hansen
Aug 02, 2024
In Effective Therapist Forum
Stepping towards recovery and improvement—be it from depression, anxiety, or chronic pain—is a journey, but with the right guidance, it can be an enlightening one. Today, we intend to shed light on the significant role of a dynamic approach to therapy called Feedback-Informed Treatment (FIT) and a revolutionary tool known as the Therapy Outcome Management System.  As you read on, grasp the empowering possibility to transform your well-being, overcoming challenges swiftly and efficiently.  "A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step." - Lao Tzu Employing the expertise of a practitioner, certified by the International Center for Clinical Excellence, who utilizes these contemporary tools, you become equipped to sail through life's rough waters with more ease and anticipation. Optimized wellbeing is no longer a distant dream, but a tangible reality. Brace yourself. You are on a course that is about to chart out powerful steps to realize a fulfilling, enriched life.  Feedback-Informed Treatment, or FIT, is a type of therapy that values your input. It's all about creating a treatment plan that's as unique as you are. FIT's main goal is to make therapy more effective by tuning into what you need and how you feel. It does this by regularly checking in on your progress and your relationship with your therapist through special measures.  These measures are endorsed by the International Center for Clinical Excellence (ICCE), who also certify practitioners. This ensures that they have the right skills and knowledge to use these measures effectively.  Considering this, the decision to seek therapy with an ICCE certified FIT practitioner using the Therapy Outcome Management System should be an easy one. Giving you, the client, the power to drive your therapy forward based on your feedback and experiences, ensures a level of personalized care that truly respects your unique journey.  The importance of having a say in your healing process cannot be overstated. You are the expert on your own life, and therefore, should have a significant say in the strategies and goals of your therapy. A FIT practitioner doesn't merely listen to your input; they use it to carefully tune their approach, optimizing the therapy in real-time. It offers a deeper level of mutual understanding, respect, and collaboration.  The partnership with you doesn't end here. With the Therapy Outcome Management System, we can further customize your therapy based on the data and insights gathered from your progress and feedback. It's essentially a powerful tool that helps us visualize your therapeutic journey, helping you navigate through the challenges and towards a better, healthier life.  Seeking help through Holistic Coaching BC isn't merely about addressing symptoms, it's about empowering you towards lasting change. The application of FIT along with the Therapy Outcome Management System facilitates a more personalized, efficient, and effective therapy experience designed to rapidly improve wellbeing and reduce symptoms of anxiety, depression, and chronic pain.  In conclusion, choosing to work with an ICCE certified FIT practitioner and applying the Therapy Outcome Management System in your therapy offers unparalleled benefits. We invite you to experience an approach where your feedback matters and plays a critical role in your healing journey. Together, we can work towards your wellness goals, making meaningful, lasting changes for a healthier, happier you. Holistic-Coaching BC Consultation https://www.wix.app/bookings/9c9987ad-c36a-410b-b53a-bf48f71049a2/service/1157fab6-efeb-42ec-ab54-0b4954091d3d/details?d=https://www.cindyhansencft.com/service-page/holistic-coaching-bc-consultation
0
6
58
Cindy Hansen
Aug 02, 2024
In Effective Therapist Forum
What if someone told you there's a secret sauce to successful therapy outcomes?(https://www.cindyhansencft.com/post/how-data-analysis-in-the-digital-age-revolutionizes-therapy-outcomes) A secret that isn't hinged on the years of education or the magnitude of experience of the therapist but rather on the symbiotic relationship forged between coach and client during sessions. Would you be curious to know? If yes, then you are in the right place. This article unveils the depth and essence of a therapeutic alliance and its profound impact on therapy success. Our spotlight is on two simple measurements that significantly influence the efficacy of therapeutic sessions – the client's level of psychological distress and the sense of teamwork that exists with the Holistic Life Coach. Dive in with us as we unravel the crux of this secret to successful therapy outcomes and how it is transforming the world of life coaching.  • Psychological distress level: An integral part of assessment and diagnosis in therapeutic sessions. Its measures provide insights into the client's emotional well-being and guide the therapy process. • Therapeutic alliance: The connection and trust established between the client and the coach. This team effort plays a pivotal role in the effectiveness of the therapy and the ultimate recovery of the client. The relationship between a client and their Holistic Life Coach is like a journey through rough terrains. The terrain represents the client's issues and challenges, while the sense of teamwork with the coach represents the compass – always pointing towards recovery.   Stay with us as we delve deeper into how a strong therapeutic alliance, (https://www.cindyhansencft.com/post/what-is-the-session-rating-scale)intertwined with accurately measuring a client's distress level, leads to more productive and successful therapy sessions. The Impact of Evidence-Based Life Coaching on Therapy Outcomes Evidence-based life coaching (EBLC) is a game-changer in therapy. It uses tried-and-tested methods that have been proven to work. This isn't about guesswork or individual bias; it's about using scientifically backed techniques, making positive outcomes more likely.  But what makes EBLC unique is how it tracks a client's improvement. By using reliable tools, coaches can gauge a client's emotional stress over time. This mutual understanding of progress not only empowers the client, but it also provides insight for the coach to fine-tune the therapy plan, if required.  Central to EBLC is the concept of a therapeutic alliance. This is a partnership between the coach and the client, which is crucial for effective therapy. The feeling of joint effort encourages clients to be involved, to voice their concerns more freely, and to stick with the therapy until they achieve their goals.  This evidence-oriented approach also fosters trust in the therapeutic alliance. When clients are aware that their therapy is rooted in scientific evidence, they may trust their coach more and have more faith in their healing process. This deepens the therapeutic alliance, leading to better therapy results.  Interestingly, EBLC levels the field concerning the coach's qualifications. Sure, education and experience are valuable, but what's even more important is the rapport between the coach and the client. By centering around proven methods and a caring relationship, EBLC shows us that a coach's success isn't tied to their degrees, but to genuine communication and effective therapy techniques.  In summary, EBLC is a structured, scientifically approved method for addressing clients' needs. It not only ensures positive outcomes but does so by building a solid partnership with the client. Evidence-based methods and the strength of the therapeutic alliance are what truly matter in therapy. And maybe that's the way it should always be. Feedback-Informed Treatment: The Secret to High Impact Life Coaching Feedback-Informed Treatment, often known as FIT, is a crucial part of effective life coaching. It's all about regularly checking in with your clients, asking for their thoughts about how the therapy is going and how their relationship with you, their coach, is developing.  Your job as a life coach is to keep an eye on two things during each session: your client's level of discomfort or distress, and how well you’re working together as a team. By consistently tracking these two elements using established measures, you can tweak your coaching strategies to better suit your client's needs. This helps build a real sense of partnership, which is often the main driver of successful therapy results.  In fact, this approach aligns perfectly with evidence-based practice.(https://www.cindyhansencft.com/post/practice-based-evidence-the-key-to-unmasking-true-treatment-efficacy) You'll be using hard facts to guide your coaching strategies. This makes sure your approach is really working for your client, leading to a more effective and beneficial therapy experience.  There's another bonus too: FIT encourages open communication between you and your client. By keeping the lines of communication open, you can tackle any problems or worries that might crop up along the way. And by involving your client in these conversations, they'll feel more in control of their own journey to wellness.  One more thing: FIT is all about taking a client-centered approach. Everyone's different, and this approach recognizes that. By focusing on your client's feedback and their view of the therapy process, you can tailor your approach to fit their unique needs and perspectives. At the end of the day, your client knows their life best, and their input is invaluable in achieving successful therapy outcomes. Identifying and Measuring Psychological Distress: Pathway to Healing A good life coach measures how stressed, anxious, or depressed a client is using special tools. These tools help figure out how a person is feeling and coping with their mental health.(https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/navigating-inclusion-personal-experience-mental-ljhyc?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_ios&utm_campaign=share_via) They give a number value to a person's distress, helping track if things are getting better or worse.  These tools can be things like surveys or questionnaires. Think of the Outcome Rating Scale (ORS), the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7-item (GAD-7) scale, or the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9). These ask clients to say how they are feeling and what they are experiencing. The answers help the life coach understand the client's distress.  Talking one-on-one with the client is another way coaches can measure distress. These discussions help the coach understand how the client is coping and what they're experiencing. These talks add more detail to the numbers from the surveys and questionnaires.  Coaches can also watch for certain behaviors or emotional reactions during sessions. These observations can give extra insight into the client's level of distress.  Sometimes, a life coach might use things like heart rate or stress hormone levels to measure distress. But these methods need special equipment and training so not all coaches use them.  But remember, these aren't used by themselves. A good life coach uses a mix of these tools to fully understand a client's distress. This lets them personalize their coaching to fit the client's needs and to check on their progress over time. Unlocking Better Therapy Outcomes: The Crucial Role of Client-Coach Teamwork Let's simplify this and speak directly to you, the reader. The 'therapeutic alliance', or the bond between you and your coach, is incredibly important in the therapy process. It's all about trust, agreeing on your therapy goals, and understanding what you need to do to reach these goals. A huge study in 2000 found a connection between the quality of this relationship and the success of therapy - showing how important that bond really is.  In fact, another study in 1991 found the same thing, and it didn't matter if the person in therapy was an adult or a teenager. In both cases, the relationship between the therapist and client had an impact. It's also been found that this bond can push you to really engage with the therapy process, leading to even better results. It's a kind of motivational boost.  And guess what? It works both ways. Therapists who have a strong bond with their clients also report feeling less 'burnt out'. So, this wonderful therapeutic alliance even boosts the mood and effectiveness of the person helping you out!  Now, while this is super important, it's not the only thing that counts. Your readiness to make a change, the skill of your coach, and the use of therapy methods that are based on solid research - all of these are super important, too. But having a strong therapeutic alliance can make all of these things work more effectively. How do Holistic-CoachingBC practitioners foster a sense of teamwork with their client? The foundation of the teamwork between a Holistic-CoachingBC practitioner and their client lies in active listening. Practitioners don't just listen to the words spoken by their clients; they also strive to fully comprehend and empathize with their emotions and experiences. This instills a sense of trust in the client, making them feel valued and secure within the therapeutic relationship.  Mutually agreed upon goal setting is another crucial component that strengthens this therapeutic alliance. Both the coach and the client collaborate to set achievable and relevant goals. This collaboration fosters a shared sense of responsibility towards attainment of these goals and deepens the bond between the client and the coach.  To further nurture this sense of teamwork, open communication is promoted in this relationship. Holistic-CoachingBC practitioners provide a safe space for their clients to voice their thoughts and fears freely, while also ensuring transparent and constructive feedback is given to the client. This encourages the client's self-awareness and expedites their therapeutic progress.  Practitioners also adopt a strengths-based perspective, emphasizing the client's strengths and assets over their issues or shortcomings. This outlook empowers the client, boosts their self-confidence, and fosters a positive and efficient therapeutic connection.  Finally, practitioners offer a consistent and dependable presence. Being reliable and consistent creates a stable and supportive environment where the client can comfortably explore their issues and work dedicatedly towards achieving their set goals. This reliability nurtures trust, an essential ingredient to any successful therapeutic connection. What have clients said about how their sense of teamwork with their coach influenced their overall therapy progress? In the therapeutic journey, clients have repeatedly highlighted the significant impact of a collaborative environment. Working together with their coach, they found the resolve to confront and address their mental struggles.  Being part of a team engenders a sense of empowerment among clients. The assurance of steadfast support from their coach helps them tackle roadblocks and drive transformative changes in their life. This collaborative sense often prompts a feeling of accountability and, in turn, speeds up their therapeutic progress.  Trust goes hand in hand with teamwork. Clients reported that a strong therapeutic alliance fostered a feeling of safety, pushing them to dig deeper into their personal concerns. The stronger their bond with their coach, the more dedicated they were to the therapy, leading to substantial improvements.  A strong team spirit brings forth a profound sense of validation. Clients felt that their coach truly understood and acknowledged their struggles, contributing to their sense of comfort. Knowing their well-being was a prime concern often proved instrumental in accelerating their recovery.  Lastly, teamwork within a therapeutic scenario fosters open communication. Clients felt encouraged to articulate their inner thoughts and emotions, secure in the knowledge that their coach was attentively listening and responding. Effective communication is indeed a cornerstone of successful therapy. Why do clients choose Holistic-CoachingBC? At Holistic Coaching BC, we pride ourselves on being an evidence-based life coaching practice. We tap into the power of scientific research to guide our coaching techniques and methods. This ensures efficiency and effectiveness in our approach to coaching and enables us to adequately quantify a client's psychological distress. Understanding a client's level of distress is integral to mapping an effective therapy journey.  The Coach-client bond is a core tenet of our philosophy at Holistic Coaching BC. We affirm the significance of this connection, as it is the cornerstone of successful therapy outcomes. Our aim is not only to bring forth our expertise, but to actively engage our clients in the process. By fostering trust, mutual respect, and understanding, we make great strides towards realizing successful therapy outcomes.  Understanding the interconnected nature of life, Holistic Coaching BC goes beyond the traditional scope. We acknowledge that your mental well-being is closely tied to your physical health, social connections, and environmental circumstances. Therefore, our coaches address all these facets to assist you in achieving a well-rounded, enriching life.  At Holistic Coaching BC, we believe that the path to improvement lies in constant appraisal and fine-tuning. By gauging your progress and the strength of our coach-client bond each session, we can tweak the therapy plan as needed. This keeps therapy aligned with your evolving needs and paves the way for successful outcomes.  So, why choose Holistic Coaching BC? With our evidence-based approach, holistic perspective, emphasis on the therapeutic bond, and dedication to constant assessment and progress, you can trust us to guide you through an effective therapy (https://www.cindyhansencft.com/profile/holisticcoachingbc/profile)journey. Initial Consultation https://www.wix.app/bookings/9c9987ad-c36a-410b-b53a-bf48f71049a2/service/1157fab6-efeb-42ec-ab54-0b4954091d3d/details?d=https://www.cindyhansencft.com/service-page/initial-consultation
Unlocking the Secrets to Successful Therapy: The Pivotal Role of Evidence-Based Life Coaching and Therapeutic Alliance content media
0
1
26

Cindy Hansen

Admin

Chief Science Officer, Holistic Research Canada

More actions

Welcome to Holistic Research Canada

We acknowledge and appreciate that we live, work and play on the ancestral, traditional, and unceded territory of the Syilx Okanagan Nation. We are confident in the quality of our copyrighted site design, logos, and content. 

Please be advised that all materials on this site are intended solely for educational purposes and should not be as a substitute for accredited mental health training. Educators are welcome to use our materials with proper attribution.

For any inquiries regarding the use of our copyrighted content, please send your request via our contact page.

Privacy Policies

This WIX.com site and its content have been developed with Gen-AI, including a collaborative Gen-AI editor/cowriter, where the human author retain the copyrights of their works.

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

©2025 by Holistic Research Canada

bottom of page